Reviewed by Marcus Knapman, BSc (Hons) Computing ·
Researched from 100+ Amazon customer reviews
· How we review
Dog poo bags might not be the most glamorous purchase, but get them wrong and you'll know about it. Earth Rated positions itself as the premium option in what's otherwise a race-to-the-bottom market, charging £11.49 for 270 bags when you can pick up basic ones for half that. The question is whether their leak-proof guarantee and eco-friendly credentials justify the extra cost.
After digging into the specs and reading through countless owner experiences, I think Earth Rated has genuinely cracked the balance between environmental responsibility and practical performance. These aren't just marketing claims dressed up in lavender scent – though the price will still make some dog walkers wince.
Earth Rated's headline claim is a 100% leak-proof guarantee, and from what I've found in user feedback, they're not overselling this. The bags measure 22cm x 33cm, which is genuinely generous – you're not doing origami to tie them up like you would with cheaper alternatives. At 0.9 mil thickness, they're substantially beefier than the tissue-thin disasters you sometimes get in multipacks.
The extra length matters more than you'd think. I've read countless reviews where people mention being able to tie proper knots without the bag splitting, and having enough material to keep your hands well clear of the business end. It's one of those things you don't appreciate until you're fumbling with a too-small bag on a wet morning in the park.
The lavender scent is surprisingly subtle – not the overpowering artificial smell I was expecting. Most users seem to find it pleasant rather than cloying, though a few mention it doesn't completely mask stronger odours. It's more about making the collection process slightly less grim than providing industrial-strength odour control.
The scent does fade over time if you're storing rolls for months, but that's hardly Earth Rated's fault. Fresh rolls have a gentle lavender aroma that dissipates fairly quickly once you're outdoors anyway.
This is where Earth Rated tries to justify the premium pricing. The bags are made from 65% post-consumer recycled plastic, which sounds impressive until you realise they're still plastic bags heading for landfill. The company claims to divert 5 million pounds of plastic annually, but let's be clear – these aren't compostable or biodegradable.
They are B Corp certified, which means they've met certain environmental and social standards. It's better than nothing, but don't kid yourself that you're saving the planet by buying poo bags. You're just choosing a slightly less awful option whilst waiting for truly sustainable alternatives to emerge.
At roughly 4.3p per bag, Earth Rated sits firmly in premium territory. Basic poo bags can cost half that, but I've found the failure rate on cheap options makes false economy a real concern. Nothing quite ruins a dog walk like a bag that splits at the crucial moment.
The 18-roll format is convenient for dispensers, though some users mention the rolls can be quite tight and occasionally tear when you're rushing. It's not a deal-breaker, but worth noting if you're often walking in a hurry.
Despite the premium positioning, Earth Rated bags aren't perfect. Some users report inconsistency between batches – occasionally getting rolls that seem thinner or more prone to tearing. The perforation between bags can be stubborn, leading to multiple bags coming off the roll when you only need one.
The lavender scent, whilst generally well-received, can be problematic for dogs or owners with sensitivities. A few reviewers mentioned their dogs seeming put off by the smell, though this appears to be fairly rare.
Earth Rated delivers on its leak-proof promise and the environmental credentials are genuine, even if not revolutionary. The premium price is justified if you value reliability and want to make a marginally better environmental choice. However, budget-conscious dog owners can find adequate alternatives for less money.
As an Amazon Associate, Smart Trends earns from qualifying purchases.
Was this review helpful?
